SUNBURY | MACEDON RANGES
Home » News » Visitor visa disappoints

Visitor visa disappoints

Sunbury mother Sukhdeep Kaur has decided to surrender her recently granted visitor visa and go into immigration detention, placing her fate in the hands of the federal government.

As reported by Star Weekly, Sunbury parents Sukhdeep Kaur and Jaswinder Singh and their two children arrived in Australia in 2015.

Both parents applied for ministerial intervention in June 2023 seeking permanent Australian residency after Sukhdeep’s employer failed to lodge a permanent residency application on her behalf.

Since that time they have received multiple visa extensions but their long-term fate remained uncertain.

Jaswinder is currently in India and is reluctant to return to Sunbury with the visa situation so uncertain.

He left Melbourne in early October to see a severely ill family member, despite an exemption to travel claim not being processed at the time of his departure and risking a three-year ban on returning to Australia.

The family member died during his visit.

Sukhdeep said that on October 10, she and her husband were notified their bid for permanent residency had failed and they were instead granted visitor visas allowing them to stay in Australia until April 10, 2025. They were also given the option of applying for a contributory parent visa or an aged parent visa.

Mrs Kaur said applying for a parent visa would be costly and would require both parents to return to India.

Daughter Ravneet said a contributory parent visa costs $48,495 with a processing time of about 14 years, while the aged parent visa costs $5100, with a 31-year wait time.

“Why do we deserve to pay the government? We worked hard, we came here legally, we gave 10 years of life to this country. Why have they ignored our hard work and 10 years of our life?” Mrs Kaur said.

“We are hard workers. We are good people. We love to live here.“

While the recently granted visitor visa would allow Sukhdeep to return to India and visit her mother, who has breast cancer, she decided that it would be too difficult under the circumstances.

“It’s better I go to the detention centre and follow their decision if they give me justice or not … then I will decide,” she said.

“The government has sent me again in limbo … it’s really really stressful, I can’t explain in words … What is the reason? Where is our fault?”

She said she has packed up most of her belongings, is investigating how to rehome her dog, and is mentally preparing to go to a detention centre in the next few weeks.

Ravneet said politicians including Hawke MP Sam Rae, a Greens senator, and a Liberal MP wrote letters of support for the family.

A spokesperson for Home Affairs said the department cannot comment on individual cases for privacy reasons.

The spokesperson said that once a minister grants a visa, their ‘ministerial intervention’ is finalised and they can’t intervene any further.

Mr Rae was contacted for comment.

Digital Editions


  • Ambulance response times closer to targets

    Ambulance response times closer to targets

    Ambulance response times have been released for October to December 2025, with response times improving in the Macedon Ranges. According to Ambulance Victoria, paramedics responded…

More News

  • Finals race tightens

    Finals race tightens

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 466957 The race for top four spots will go down to the final two rounds in the Gisborne and District Cricket Association McIntyre Cup.…

  • Additional health test for newborns

    Additional health test for newborns

    Victoria has become the first Australian jurisdiction to include sickle cell disease in its universal newborn health screening program. This expansion brings the total number of rare but serious conditions…

  • Residents encouraged to mind water usage

    Residents encouraged to mind water usage

    Residents across Melbourne’s north and west are being called upon to reduce their water consumption as state storage levels fall to 61% of capacity. This current level marks a decrease…

  • Fruity festival returns

    Fruity festival returns

    If you have a green thumb, are an aspiring gardener– or just really love fruit trees– then there’s an event for you. The much-loved Summer Fruit Tree Festival will burst…

  • Finalists announced for AFL community venue award

    Finalists announced for AFL community venue award

    The 2025 finalists have been announced for the AFL’s Ken Gannon Football Facilities Award, recognising the projects that set the benchmark in best-practice design and development to help the continued…

  • New toolkit to help women report abuse in sport

    New toolkit to help women report abuse in sport

    Australian women face significant risk when disclosing gender-based violence in sport and quite often receive inadequate or harmful responses according to new research from La Trobe Univeristy. The research project,…

  • Celebrity alcohol ads slip into teens’ Insta feeds

    Celebrity alcohol ads slip into teens’ Insta feeds

    Celebrities are promoting their own alcohol products on Instagram without a clear disclosure of advertising content and almost all posts are visible to underage users, according to new research from…

  • Funding to improve road safety across Victoria

    Funding to improve road safety across Victoria

    Victorian community organisations and groups will get a total of $600,000 in grants from the Transport Accident Commission (TAC) to develop and implement local road safety projects. The funding, part…

  • Multicultural health committee expanded

    Multicultural health committee expanded

    Victoria’s Multicultural Health Advisory Committee has been expanded in an effort to make the state’s health system more inclusive and increasingly diverse. Health Minister Mary-Anne Thomas unveiled the strengthened and…

  • Grant to make Thunder grow

    Grant to make Thunder grow

    New East Sunbury female football ambassador Emma Grant wants to ensure the female footballers get the same opportunities as male counterparts. The former AFLW player and now Richmond AFLW assistant…