SUNBURY | MACEDON RANGES
Home » News » Storm asthma errors detailed

Storm asthma errors detailed

By Alesha Capone

 

A damning report shows that triple-0 operators made several errors that may have contributed to delays in getting help to some of the people who died in the 2016 thunderstorm asthma event.

The Inspector-General for Emergency Management’s report into emergency services’ response during the thunderstorm asthma tragedy states that some operators did not advise callers there were long waits for ambulances, but were required to tell people that “the ambulance is on the way”, regardless of whether paramedics had been dispatched or not.

In the case of Hoppers Crossing woman Hope Carnevali (also known as Hope Marsh), an operator correctly recorded she had a history of asthma, but this caused software to downgrade her case as a priority.

Hope, 20, died in front of her family’s house as she and her relatives waited for an ambulance which arrived 30 minutes after it was called.

The report states that triple-0 operators received an “unprecedented” 2666 calls in a 12-hour period during the thunderstorm asthma event in which eight people died.

Between 3pm on November 21, 2016 and 6am the following day, the Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority received 2666 requests for paramedics to assist with emergency and non-emergency cases, of which 962 were related to breathing problems.

The report notes the Emergency Services Telecommunications Authority has upgraded training for its operators.

“We offer our condolences to the families and friends of the people who died as a result of the unprecedented thunderstorm asthma event,” the authority said in a statement.

 

– with

The Age

Digital Editions


  • Theft in Mt Macedon

    Theft in Mt Macedon

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Police have arrested a Maidstone man following a theft in Mt Macedon. On 25 January, a car was…

More News

  • Help for heart kids

    Help for heart kids

    Every day in Australia, eight babies are born with a childhood-onset heart disease (CoHD), and this February HeartKids is calling on Australians to help support these children and their families…

  • Slow down around schools

    Slow down around schools

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 With Victorian students returning to school for Term 1 of 2026, police are reminding motorists to slow down and take extra care around…

  • Ambos support fire-affected wildlife

    Ambos support fire-affected wildlife

    Ambulance Victoria (AV) staff and volunteers have banded together over the last few weeks to provide emergency care to fire-affected communities across Victoria, with recent efforts going towards supporting the…

  • Bushfire smoke creates dangerous conditions for people with asthma

    Bushfire smoke creates dangerous conditions for people with asthma

    Asthma Australia says air pollution from bushfires across Victoria dramatically increases the risk of asthma attacks. Bushfire smoke contains fine particles and other pollutants that can penetrate deep into the…

  • Nominations open for the Victorian Honour Roll of Women

    Nominations open for the Victorian Honour Roll of Women

    In a move to shine a spotlight on the trailblazing women of Victoria, the state government has opened nominations for the 2026 Victorian Honour Roll of Women. The roll celebrates…

  • Write on

    Write on

    Calling all writers, creatives, and storytellers alike. Moorabool is celebrating local storytelling as the Peter Carey Short Story Awards marks 10 years of recognising Moorabool writers through the Best Local…

  • Your voice, your needs: National Parkinson’s survey

    Your voice, your needs: National Parkinson’s survey

    People living with Parkinson’s and their families and carers can help shape future medical and allied health care through a national survey. Organisers are keen to ensure Australia-wide participation in…

  • Spend Valentine’s at Scienceworks

    Spend Valentine’s at Scienceworks

    When couples think of romantic locations to spend Valentine’s Day, science museums are generally not very high on their list. But that might be about to change this year when…

  • Sunshine welcomes Lunar New Year

    Sunshine welcomes Lunar New Year

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528389 The Sunshine Lunar New Year Festival will return this year as a vibrant, free multicultural community celebration in the heart of Sunshine. The…

  • Burras coaching change

    Burras coaching change

    Diggers Rest has had a late coaching change ahead of the Riddell District Netball League season. The Burras announced last year that Deepak Patu would coach the side in 2026,…