SUNBURY | MACEDON RANGES
Home » News » Coroner to hold inquest into pub crash that killed five

Coroner to hold inquest into pub crash that killed five

A coroner will hold an inquest into the deaths of five people who were struck and killed when a diabetic driver ploughed into a beer garden.

Pratibha Sharma, 44, her daughter Anvi, 9, and partner Jatin Kumar, 30, and their friend Vivek Bhatia, 38, and his son Vihaan, 11, all died in the November 2023 collision in central Victoria.

They were among patrons sitting at the Royal Daylesford Hotel’s beer garden when William Swale, a type-1 diabetic, suffered a severe hypoglycaemic episode and crashed into them.

Prosecutors claimed Mr Swale, a Mount Macedon resident, had ignored warning signs about his declining glucose levels and was negligent in driving from 5.36pm that evening.

He was charged with 14 offences, including five counts of culpable driving causing death, but a magistrate dismissed the case against him in September 2024 after finding Mr Swale’s actions were involuntary.

The Office of Public Prosecutions in November confirmed Mr Swale would not face further charges over the Daylesford crash.

Coroner Dimitra Dubrow on Tuesday said the coronial investigation had been reopened and an inquest into the five deaths will be held in March 2026.

The scope of the inquest is yet to be determined, although Ms Dubrow flagged outdoor dining risks and safe driving by diabetic drivers will be among the issues examined.

A traffic expert and endocrinologist have already been contacted to provide statements to the court, the coroner said.

Counsel assisting Rishi Nathwani KC confirmed there could be more than 60 witnesses in the coronial brief, including civilians, police officers and medical experts.

Mr Swale was contacted by the coroner but had so far exercised his legal right not to provide a statement, Mr Nathwani said.

He told the court it was not in dispute that Mr Swale suffered a severe hypoglycaemic episode at the time of the collision.

Ms Dubrow said the inquest would not “rehash” the criminal case but the circumstances surrounding the deaths would be considered before any findings are made.

A further directions hearing will be held in coming months to finalise the scope of the inquest.

Digital Editions


More News

  • Macedon CFA open day

    Macedon CFA open day

    The Macedon CFA is opening its doors for a Community Day and Fundraiser. Visit the station on Saturday 28 February for a day of family fun, food, and special guests…

  • Women’s history centre stage

    Women’s history centre stage

    A special one-off theatrical performance is coming to the Kyneton Town Hall in celebration of International Women’s Day. In 2026, the theme for International Women’s Day is #BalanceTheScales – a…

  • Lions skin checks yield promising results

    Lions skin checks yield promising results

    A skin check bus hosted by Macedon Ranges Lions Clubs has offered insight to the local community about the importance of getting checked. In early February, the Gisborne, Kyneton, Woodend,…

  • Probus celebrates 50 years

    Probus celebrates 50 years

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 534248 The Woodlands Ladies Probus Club is celebrating Probus’ 50th anniversary. Founded in 1976 in Australia, Probus has grown into a network of social…

  • Top for Sunbury

    Top for Sunbury

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 515749 Club Sunbury has given itself the best chance come Bowls Victoria weekend pennant, division 1, section 1 finals. Every shot was vital in…

  • Free immunisations sessions

    Free immunisations sessions

    Macedon Ranges council provides free immunisations as set out by the National Immunisation Program. When you attend a council immunisation session you should bring your child’s health book and Medicare…

  • Ambulance response times closer to targets

    Ambulance response times closer to targets

    Ambulance response times have been released for October to December 2025, with response times improving in the Macedon Ranges. According to Ambulance Victoria, paramedics responded to 738 code one call…

  • Calling all artists

    Calling all artists

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 336543 Applications for the Hume Gallery annual exhibition are now open, offering emerging artists the chance to display their work. The program aims to…

  • Join the gardening crew

    Join the gardening crew

    Macedon & Mount Macedon Community House’s (MMMCH) gardens are being kept in tip-top shape by its volunteer gardening crew. Over the past 12 months, volunteers have developed a variety of…

  • New Landcare group for Kerrie

    New Landcare group for Kerrie

    A new Landcare group may soon be formed for the Kerrie area. The Upper Deep Creek Landcare Network, with support from Macedon Ranges council, has organised a community meeting at…